Two Paths, One Coach: Pitso’s Sundowns Dilemma or Bafana Return
The debate around Pitso Mosimane’s next move continues to dominate South African football, with both Mamelodi Sundowns and Bafana Bafana firmly in the conversation — but for very different reasons.
Sundowns: Power, not money, the real issue
Speculation about a sensational return to Chloorkop has gathered pace, but insiders suggest the main stumbling block is structural rather than financial. According to SoccerBeat, discussions have been complicated by questions around authority within Sundowns’ football setup.
Speaking on Betway Beat, Peter du Toit explained that Sundowns’ modern sporting-director model — overseen by Flemming Berg — is designed to prioritise continuity over individual influence. Mosimane, by contrast, has historically preferred a hands-on role in recruitment and squad planning, shaped by his unprecedented success on the continent.
The key question is whether those two approaches can coexist. Would Mosimane be prepared to work within an established hierarchy, or would Sundowns need to adjust their structure to accommodate his methods? Du Toit suggested this balance of power, not salary demands, is the real obstacle.
Supporters remain split. Some believe Mosimane’s pedigree warrants greater control, while others warn that dismantling a system that has delivered sustained dominance could be a risky gamble.
Bafana Bafana: “Yes, I’m available”
While Sundowns weigh their options, Mosimane has openly signalled interest in a potential return to the national team. With Hugo Broos expected to step aside after the 2026 FIFA World Cup, the Bafana post could soon be vacant.
Speaking on Marawa Sports Worldwide in December 2025, Mosimane said the timing appeals to him, pointing to strong youth pipelines and renewed belief in South African football. However, he stressed that any return would need to be part of a long-term, well-supported project — not a short-term reaction to poor results.
Other names remain in the frame, including Benni McCarthy, currently working at international level, and DR Congo coach Sébastien Desabre. Broos himself has also hinted that assistant Helman Mkhalele could be a natural successor.
For now, focus remains on upcoming competitions — but whether at club or country level, Mosimane’s future is set to remain one of the most compelling storylines in South African football.