Why Tshegofatso Mabasa could hurt Orlando Pirates in Chiefs colours
The growing talk of Tshegofatso Mabasa swapping Orlando Pirates colours for Kaizer Chiefs has sparked a fierce debate among supporters — and for good reason.
Once regarded as one of the most ruthless finishers in the Betway Premiership, Mabasa now finds himself on the fringes at Orlando Pirates. The 29-year-old has slipped down the striking pecking order behind Evidence Makgopa and emerging forward Yanela Mbuthuma, a situation that has limited him to just five league appearances this season and effectively ended any immediate hopes of a Bafana Bafana recall.
Despite his reduced role, reports linking Mabasa with a shock move to Kaizer Chiefs have divided opinion. Some Pirates fans believe it is time to move on, while others warn that letting a proven goalscorer join a direct rival would be a monumental mistake.
Those in the latter camp point to Mabasa’s pedigree. Confidence and continuity, they argue, are all that separate him from rediscovering his best form — and Chiefs could be the perfect environment for that revival. Handing such a striker to an opponent is a gamble that could come back to haunt the Buccaneers.
Pirates, meanwhile, appear to be planning ahead. The club is closing in on the signing of New Zealand international Andre de Jong from Stellenbosch FC, with insiders suggesting he could be one of three high-profile additions. De Jong’s ability to operate just behind the striker hints at a tactical shift rather than a direct replacement for Mabasa.
With Makgopa firmly first choice and Mbuthuma viewed as a capable understudy, Pirates may feel covered. But football history is littered with examples of clubs strengthening rivals by selling proven talent too cheaply — or too soon.
If Mabasa does end up leading the line elsewhere, especially at Naturena, Pirates may find themselves watching a familiar name punish them from the wrong end of the pitch.